From a first time blogger, thoughts about life from an American missionary now living in the US after years in Russia and doing a lot of back and forth. Family stuff, Christian content, sports innuendo and lots of quotes from good books.

Sunday, November 06, 2005

Good for One, Good for All (?)

It is interesting how in one culture to one group, a message is considered as on target as possible. To a group holding the same faith though in another culture, it brings harm and confusion.

BEIJING — The Prayer of Jabez by Bruce Wilkinson, one of the best-selling non-fiction books in the past ten years, has gutted China's house church movement, say observers.
"Chinese Christians used to sacrifice everything for Christ. Now they only want God to bless them," says one Chinese elder who has served five prison terms for planting churches. He and others say China's Christians have "grown soft with navel-gazing" and have lost their tolerance for persecution.
Copies of The Prayer of Jabez began circulating in China in 2001. Many Christians began "talking endlessly about God expanding their borders and keeping them free from pain," says one Chinese pastor whose weekly prayer meeting shrunk to half its previous size.
"Instead of asking God to strengthen the Chinese church they pray for personal fulfillment. They ignore all the Bible except Jabez," he says.
Sun Young, 24, says he and other Christians are tired of hearing only about "the way of the cross."
"Jabez changed my life. I pray every morning, 'God, let your hand be with me and keep me from harm,'" he says.
Unlike his parents, he does not want to suffer for Christ, but rather hopes to flourish in his personal giftings. "Jabez showed us a new way," he says.
According to 1 Chronicles 4:9-10 Jabez was "more honorable than his brothers. His mother had named him Jabez, saying, 'I gave birth to him in pain.' Jabez cried out to the God of Israel, 'Oh, that you would bless me and enlarge my territory! Let your hand be with me, and keep me from harm so that I will be free from pain.' And God granted his request."
As the Jabez book spreads to China's interior, the house church movement, once a model of Christian endurance, is bracing for even greater loss of members.

9 Comments:

Blogger Wade said...

Lord knows that I'm no fan of Jabez, but I'd love to see where that article came from. Are you sure it's legit?

10:45 PM

 
Blogger Rob said...

Sarcasm got the best of me. No, it is not legit. I kinda hesitated sticking it out there because I've been duped on Matt Elliott's blog more times than I can count (I thought AOL really would give me a million dollars if turned over my address list to them...I still do actually!). All sucker's ceased being born shortly after I came on the scene apparently.

In Russia, this book has been the source of much interesting conversation with long time Christians. They really "don't get it" like a lot of North American Christians do.

The point was just to get me/us to think. You've been around long enough to catch a phony when you see it I guess.

And where was this found? At a place I love to frequent. See www.larknews.com.

P.S. Chinese house church Christians know better....much better!

1:23 PM

 
Blogger Matt Elliott said...

You'll be happy to know that I fell for it at first, Rob! :-)

Check out the one on "Why I'm Not Emergent" on my blog today. It's hilarious!

6:18 PM

 
Blogger Brooks Inc. said...

Rob-

I did not realize it was a fake... My mom(also not a Jabez fan)was the first one to tell me "before you ask the Lord to enlarge your territory you make sure everyone in the one you have knows Him." Her words made me look at it a bit differently than many others do.

Blessings on you and Traci...I love you guys!

Becky

4:47 PM

 
Blogger Rob said...

Becky - when I say the way that Americans get it, I did not mean to say that Americans get it the right way. It's an odd little book in a lot of ways. Americans obviously cling to short fixes and this prayer sure makes it seem like there is a short fix.

10:05 PM

 
Blogger Lovell's Lookout said...

R0b- great writing- You had me hook line and sinker... I was beginning to get sick to my stomach. I am constantly talking with people who have taken the "latest" fad and made it their "new Theology". We are always looking for a quick fix to pain, suffering, and problems. I have always thought that much of the "health/Wealth" theology today wouldn't fly in the impoverished places.. and ignores much of the bibles "theology of contentment" and suffering.

I have a good question for dialogue.."What do you do with the legitimate promises of God to bless people so they can bless others?" I have several friends who give hundreds of thousands of their dollars to support missionaries all over the world. They believe God has blessed them so they can spread His Kingdom. They pray the prayer of Jabez(though only a small part of their prayer life) and the "Kingdom" is about God's Kingdom and not just thier own bank account-- they truly want "God's Kingdom" advanced-- Is THat wrong? ( I am not saying you would say it is- just talking about the anti-Jabez sentiment) While not defending the accesses and self-serving focuses of recent movements and books, do we just throw out all the scriptures about God blessing to the exclusion of the one's that we feel most comfortable with? If I am not a fan of Jabez- does that mean I am not a fan of what God did for Jabez in the bible- or just the book Wilkinson wrote? Or that if God does anything "good" for someone that I have to pass it off as "immature", uninformed, pre-postmodern, self-induldgent Christianity? (I am not writing this concerning your blog- just a trend I see among many "post-modern" thinkers that like to bash some churches that include "God's Blessing" in some of their preaching/teaching.) I realize the the American church is the epitomy of self-indulgent, Me centered focus but I do not want to throw out God's truths just because of abuses. People have abused Grace- I still think we need it, people abuse the bible- I still read it, people have faked and abused "Spiritual Gifts"- they did in Corinth and we still need them. People preach (me) centric messages about God's blessing/finances, yet I still need him to bless mine- hopefully so I can use it for His things.

Anyways Rob- I respect the way you think, love your writing, and would love to dialogue about some of these things.. I would also love to see you do a sarcastic piece-- say from China, Africa, or Brazil-- as to why the American churches are so "power-less".

P.S. There is some of the "Jabez" book I liked and some I didn't. Like any scripture taken out of context and made the "center peice" for a whole theological paradigm- there are huge pitfalls...

5:42 PM

 
Blogger Timothy D said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

8:19 AM

 
Blogger Timothy D said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

8:21 AM

 
Blogger Rob said...

Good point LL! I gotta admit that parts of the Jabez deal really struck a chord in my heart when I read it. I also gotta admit a bunch of hooey was being talked about and presumptions made by a lot of Christians as a result of it. Both from the book though and from some frustrations I was dealing with in my ministry at the time, I did pray that my territories would be enlarged and boy have they!! ¾ of the open doors we have in Russia today are through non-believers. That speaks of an enlarged territory. Connection? You decide.

God indeed works through some of the most broken structures that society has to offer even when what might be broken has "Christian" and "Faith Based" written all over it. I'm not gonna say he can't do that. Actually, I'm going to say that is one of his most wonderful demonstrations of his sovereignty! Growing up a church of Christ kid was a blessing in many ways but it did little to show me the width and breadth of the body of Christ. I've been in catch up mode for years now as I've looked at other broken (for are we all not broken in some way?) denominations and seen the hand of God at work through them. I learned the heart of worship from charismatics though I am not one (at least in as much as many would define charismatic today). I learned a form of Bible study that I strongly adhere to from Baptists though I don't particularly look or sound very Baptist. Catholics have been my best example of charity. I've pillaged the business world and field of psychology for insight tapping into and changing people's beliefs, attitudes, and values. In our ministry, we often use marketing terms as freely as we do ministry terms. I have no problem with that all. I tend to believe that all truth is from God so it's all there for me to use to his glory. Therefore, even through skewed means, God speaks and often works quite well.

I agree many today are quick to poo poo anything not emergent. I was on the way to that kind of thinking a few years back and then the strangest things started to happen - I found relevancy and depth in some of the oldest, most modern forms of worship and spiritual disciplines. The old writings seemed fresh again. The old forms sometimes actually held relevance. There is much to be had from the emerging church movement but I can't chuck everything that the modernist view brought our way too. Some will and maybe some must but I can't do it.

As I get further and further away from my preferences (be it worship style, church structure, verbiage, leadership forms, etc.), I think I am able to see again just how wonderful God is to work through institutions and situations that seem foreign, weird, or uncomfortable to me. My view of the Kingdom of God has exploded the last few years as this handle of thinking has taken hold.

Yes, the Prayer of Jabez has been marketed to the nth degree and gobs of money have been made through it. I don't know Bruce Wilkerson so I'm not going to judge him one way or the other. Even if I did know him I hope I would not (because I know I should not) judge him. God has used that book in Russia to really bless some friends of mine. I can't argue with God about that. Come to think of it, he's used it to kinda bless me to. Ah, God! His ways are surely not mine.

3:03 PM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home